The line-up for Lawless drove expectations way up; with a star studded cast including Tom Hardy, Jessica Chastain, Guy Pearce, Gary Oldman, Mia Wasikowska, and Shia LeBeouf (maybe not so much Shia) and Aussie director John Hillcoat (The Road, The Proposition). The end result, failed to live up to such great expectations.
Lawless follows the stories of the Bondurants of Franklin County; brothers running a successful liquor business in the times of prohibition. Between Forrest’s (Hardy, Inception, The Dark Knight Rises) legend status and Jack (LeBeouf, Transformers franchise)’s budding love the brothers must navigate the new pressure of Special Detective Charlie Rakes (Pearce, The Hurt Locker, Memento).
In a rather mediocre film, there are still dazzling aspects. Hillcoat certainly knows how to shoot a film; seamlessly navigating between the misty country roads (take me home) and the luminous, rustic summers. The way he plays with shadows sculpts scenes of beauty reminiscent of noir films, drawing both complex and enticing set pieces. The cast gives strong performances; from the solemnly brutal Tom Hardy to the vivacious and mysterious Jessica Chastain. Even Shia holds his own on the screen against such high caliber talent, and makes for a sympathetic protagonist.
That’s where the film’s exceptionality ends. The plot is muddled and mundane, being carried by narration that doesn’t mind dragging it’s feet. There are many sequences that seem so extraneous and unnecessary it becomes difficult to focus on aspects pertinent to the main plot. Characterization in this film do nothing to help a rather sluggish and heavy script; each character is very one-note, lacking any sort of complex dimension. The only two women in the film were completely expendable as characters. They serve only as obligatory love interests for their male counterparts. It all makes for rather standard and boring fare; in a film that dares to be landmark and modern classic, it doesn’t live up to its name and sure doesn’t break any laws.